Well, this was interesting. I know a lot of viewers weren't fans of this, but especially with the Singular Point series coming up I'm curious how opinions here stood on Urobuchi's trilogy (spoilers ahead):
There's a lot in the first movie that I don't entirely remember, but it's safe to say a good reason for that is that most of the movie doesn't matter beyond trilogy setup. It's mostly slow and straightforward, and the near-end point appears to state how the rest of the trilogy will play out--just as it wants its viewers to think. The first movie serves to do two things: to set up the story and to introduce mainstream audiences to screenwriter Gen Urobuchi, whose preferred writing style seems to be hand-feeding viewers the story until he flips the table into their stomachs to set up the actual story. The second film is probably my favorite in the trilogy, mostly because boy, don't I love a good dilemma. Setting revenge at the cost of one's will and humanity is a very strong story element, both as narrative and as symbolism, and it's pulled off pretty much perfectly here. The third installment has some extremely powerful moments and concludes at least one character arc very impressively (and a Lovecraftian kaiju will almost always be fun), though I do have a quibble on how long the first act spends talking about how weird things are. Perhaps the finale's most insightful point sets Godzilla as a force of nature to be acknowledged but not destroyed--which has certainly been explored before, but it feels new with the context of a character driven by hatred of the beast and having to move on from it throughout the series.
The trilogy is far from perfect. While I'd disagree with complaints that the relative lack of monster action ruins the experience, a few themes and motifs cut away from what it strives for. The trilogy appears to be about humanity itself--impressive for a trilogy with several kaiju, two alien races and moth people among the cast--and while that's not a bad thing, its humanist approach seems to lose some details; what seems like it should be a balanced and cautionary tale turns to a limited, almost nihilistic work at times. Both religion and science are rather inexplicably framed as antithetical to humanity, between a Lovecraftian take on a ritualistic monster-summoning and anti-Godzilla technology requiring its users to sacrifice their free will. (Religion gets a liiittle leeway through a certain cameo in perhaps one of the most emotionally powerful scenes of the third film, but to my memory technology is never given a similar way out.) Its racial implications aren't much better: by the end of the trilogy, it's clear that both the dark-skinned aliens and the blond, kinda-Caucasian ones' cultural flaws make them hardly better than villains. (Would that the Lovecraft influence ended with the cool Ghidorah concept as opposed to adding his antireligious/xenophobic attitudes.) For a film series that tries to pick humanity apart and put it together again, one can't help but feel it left a couple of pieces out.
Overall, the trilogy discusses science, religion, their potential for being abused, free will, humanity and hatred while weaving in the suggestion that Godzilla shouldn't be seen as a threat to be beaten. These motifs, executed via Urobuchi's effective-as-ever writing, form a connected trilogy that was almost--almost--a stunning, game-changing entry to a franchise over 60 years old. Its flawed themes undoubtedly subtract from the story's effectiveness, though, especially as the trilogy goes along, so whether I'd actively recommend the trilogy is a difficult question. Perhaps the best I can say is that it's a well-prepared, intricately flavored entrée that could just do with a grain of salt.
Thoughts on Gen Urobuchi's Godzilla Anime Trilogy
Talk about Annie May here
- Mxylv
- Humongous
- Posts: 584
- Joined: Sat Jul 18, 2015 2:50 pm
- Favorite series: Ultraman Nexus
- 2nd Favorite Series: Kamen Rider Gaim
- Favorite Actor?: Daisuke Terai
- Favorite Band: GaGaalinG
- Alignment: Neutral Good
- Quote: Where wisdom and valor fail, all that remains is faith. And it can overcome all.
- Location: Nebula M-78
Thoughts on Gen Urobuchi's Godzilla Anime Trilogy
Watching:
Kamen Rider Kuuga, Gotchard
Watched:
KR W, Gaim, Ghost - Build, Geats
Ultraman '66, Leo, Great, Nexus - U7X, Ginga - Blazar
Donbrothers
GS Sho, HwTM, Dogengers S1-4
Kamen Rider Kuuga, Gotchard
Watched:
KR W, Gaim, Ghost - Build, Geats
Ultraman '66, Leo, Great, Nexus - U7X, Ginga - Blazar
Donbrothers
GS Sho, HwTM, Dogengers S1-4
When in doubt,
Jump to
- Rules
- ↳ Rules and Announcements (Newbies, read first)
- Help and Support
- ↳ Tech Support
- ↳ Downloads & Site Help
- ↳ Playback Help
- ↳ Joining the staff
- ↳ Bit Torrent Seeding Request
- TV-Nihon Active Shows
- ↳ Other Projects
- ↳ NetaJin
- ↳ Princess Jellyfish
- ↳ Super Heroine CharaBen Cooking
- ↳ Trick
- ↳ Tokusatsu GAGAGA
- ↳ Tire People
- ↳ Garo Hagane wo Tsugumono
- ↳ Kamen Rider Gotchard
- ↳ Ohsama Sentai King-Ohger
- ↳ Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon
- ↳ Show Summary Site
- TV-Nihon Completed Projects
- ↳ Licensed
- ↳ Anime (Completed)
- ↳ Fairy Musketeer Akazukin
- ↳ Gaiking Legend of Daiku Maryu
- ↳ HeartCatch Precure
- ↳ Machine Robo Rescue
- ↳ Onmyou Taisenki
- ↳ Powerpuff Girls Z
- ↳ Yu-Gi-Oh
- ↳ Zoids Genesis
- ↳ ChouSeiShin Series
- ↳ ChouSeiShin GranSazer
- ↳ GenSeiShin JustiRiser
- ↳ ChouSeiKantai Sazer X
- ↳ Jdorama (Completed)
- ↳ akihabara@deep
- ↳ DaiMajin Kanon
- ↳ Densha Otoko
- ↳ Fuuma No Kojirou Live
- ↳ Keitai Sousakan 7
- ↳ Sexy Voice and Robo
- ↳ Kamen Rider (Completed)
- ↳ Kamen Rider Kuuga
- ↳ Kamen Rider Agito
- ↳ Kamen Rider Ryuki
- ↳ Kamen Rider 555
- ↳ Kamen Rider Blade
- ↳ Kamen Rider Hibiki
- ↳ Kamen Rider Kabuto
- ↳ Kamen Rider Den-O
- ↳ Kamen Rider The Next
- ↳ Kamen Rider Kiva
- ↳ Kamen Rider Decade
- ↳ Kamen Rider W
- ↳ Kamen Rider OOO
- ↳ Kamen Rider Fourze
- ↳ Kamen Rider Wizard
- ↳ Kamen Rider Gaim
- ↳ Kamen Rider Drive
- ↳ Kamen Rider Ghost
- ↳ Kamen Rider Amazons
- ↳ Kamen Rider Ex-Aid
- ↳ Kamen Rider Build
- ↳ Kamen Rider Zi-O
- ↳ Kamen Rider Zero-One
- ↳ Kamen Rider Saber
- ↳ Kamen Rider Revice
- ↳ Kamen Rider Geats
- ↳ Super Sentai (Completed)
- ↳ Sentai-Kyouryuu Sentai ZyuRanger
- ↳ Sentai-Gosei Sentai DaiRanger
- ↳ Sentai-Denji Sentai MegaRanger
- ↳ Sentai-Mirai Sentai TimeRanger
- ↳ Tokusou Sentai DekaRanger
- ↳ Mahou Sentai MagiRanger
- ↳ GoGo Sentai Boukenger
- ↳ Jyuken Sentai GekiRanger
- ↳ Engine Sentai Go-Onger
- ↳ Samurai Sentai Shinkenger
- ↳ Tensou Sentai Goseiger
- ↳ Kaizoku Sentai Gokaiger
- ↳ Hikounin Sentai AkibaRanger
- ↳ Tokumei Sentai Go-Busters
- ↳ ZyuDen Sentai Kyouryuuger
- ↳ Ressha Sentai Toqger
- ↳ Shuriken Sentai Ninninger
- ↳ Doubutsu Sentai Jyuohger
- ↳ Uchuu Sentai KyuuRanger
- ↳ Kaitou Sentai LupinRanger VS Keisatsu Sentai PatRanger
- ↳ Super Sentai Saikyou Battle
- ↳ Kishiryuu Sentai Ryusoulger
- ↳ Mashin Sentai Kiramager
- ↳ Sentai-Kikai Sentai Zenkaiger
- ↳ Avatarou Sentai DonBrothers
- ↳ Ultraman
- ↳ Misc Ultraman
- ↳ Ultraman Dyna
- ↳ Ultraman Nexus
- ↳ Ultraman Mebius
- ↳ UltraSeven X
- ↳ Ultraman Ginga
- ↳ Ultraman Orb (Spin-offs)
- ↳ Ultraman R/B
- ↳ Tokusatsu Misc (Completed)
- ↳ Cutie Honey
- ↳ Garo
- ↳ Garo Movies
- ↳ Garo Anime
- ↳ Makai Senki
- ↳ ~Yami wo Terasu Mono~
- ↳ Zero -Black Blood-
- ↳ -Makai no Hana-
- ↳ -Gold Storm- Shou
- ↳ -Makai Retsuden-
- ↳ Zero -Dragon Blood-
- ↳ Kami no Kiba -JINGA-
- ↳ -Versus Road-
- ↳ Garo Season 1
- ↳ Giga Tokusatsu
- ↳ Kodai Shoujo Dogu-chan
- ↳ Madan Senki RyuKenDo
- ↳ Shibuya 15
- ↳ Shougeki Gouraigan
- ↳ Tomica Hero Rescue Force
- ↳ Tomica Hero Rescue Fire
- ↳ Transformers (Completed)
- ↳ The Headmasters
- ↳ Masterforce
- ↳ Victory
- ↳ Super Link
- ↳ Galaxy Force
- ↳ Transformers Go!
- ↳ TV-Nihon On Hold Projects
- ↳ GEAR Fighter Dendoh
- ↳ Rockman.EXE Axess
- ↳ Transformers Car Robots
- ↳ Yes! PreCure 5
- ↳ GameCenter CX
- All The Other Stuff
- ↳ Off Topic
- ↳ Random
- ↳ Japanese Culture Appreciation
- ↳ Media Gallery
- ↳ Community stuff
- ↳ Bartering
- ↳ Fanfics
- ↳ Entertainments
- ↳ Actors
- ↳ Anime
- ↳ Gundam
- ↳ Games
- ↳ Monster Hunter
- ↳ Manga/Comics
- ↳ Movies
- ↳ Toys
- ↳ TV
- ↳ Americanized stuff
- ↳ Other Heroes
- ↳ Kamen Rider
- ↳ Sentai
- ↳ Submit Links
- ↳ Notify Broken Links
- ↳ Anime DDL
- ↳ Garo DDL
- ↳ JDrama DDL
- ↳ Misc & Other Tokusatsu DDL
- ↳ Transformers DDL