Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Forum rules
Wiki Link
Wiki Link
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Apparently it is going to be North-America only...
As an European I will probably not be able to watch it
Luckily you guys at TV-N are not dropping this show
As an European I will probably not be able to watch it
Luckily you guys at TV-N are not dropping this show
- Triple M
- Destron Emperor
- Posts: 472
- Joined: Fri Jun 20, 2008 1:30 am
- Favorite series: Destron
- 2nd Favorite Series: Destron
- Dreamy: Destron
- Favorite Actor?: Destron
- Favorite Band: Destron
- Alignment: Chaotic Evil
- My boom: Destron
- Quote: *HAIL DESTRON*
- Type: INTP Architect
- Location: Destron
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
I'm watching it now. Just so everyone knows, it totally sucks in every way. Please look forward to more complete unedited subs from us
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
So after waiting an hour and a half for them to finally get the video up (holy crap, I can't believe they didn't have a backup plan in place), the video finally goes up, and I can't bear to get through more than 2 minutes of it.
The announcer is what really killed it for me. An guy doing his worst game show host impersonation with no concept of proper pronunciation is dubbed over the original video, with a significantly higher volume than the rest of the show in order to drown out the original Japanese announcer (who you still hear in the background anyway). It's such a needless thing to do, and done so poorly and is just so distracting and annoying. It's like going to the movies and having some jerk talking on his cell phone sitting in front of you. Maybe he's also really tall or wearing a big hat so you can't see very well either, I don't know.
I am begging you, TV-Nihon subs of this show cannot return soon enough. It's been a year, and we've now seen what the efforts of others will bring us.
The announcer is what really killed it for me. An guy doing his worst game show host impersonation with no concept of proper pronunciation is dubbed over the original video, with a significantly higher volume than the rest of the show in order to drown out the original Japanese announcer (who you still hear in the background anyway). It's such a needless thing to do, and done so poorly and is just so distracting and annoying. It's like going to the movies and having some jerk talking on his cell phone sitting in front of you. Maybe he's also really tall or wearing a big hat so you can't see very well either, I don't know.
I am begging you, TV-Nihon subs of this show cannot return soon enough. It's been a year, and we've now seen what the efforts of others will bring us.
-
- Adventure
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 6:25 am
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Everyone is saying it is the worst thing ever. At least those of you in the US get to experience the pain...
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
I wasn't completely opposed to the compromise of dubbed narration and subbed dialogue. In theory. But after watching I have to say the narrator is very overbearing. The Japanese narrator had a sort of serious tone that enhanced the documentary-like atmosphere of the show, but this guy, well, I feel like I'm watching a promo for a monster truck rally. "Will Arino clear the next stage!? Find out on Sunday! Sunday! Sunday!" That's a slight exaggeration, but not by much. It's the same kind of "extreme" narration you hear on a lot of American reality shows. I was really trying to be open-minded about this, but this guy was bad. The fact that the over-dubbing necessarily drowns out a lot of the dramatic incidental music didn't help either.
- TG23
- Gabu
- Posts: 273
- Joined: Sat Mar 28, 2009 8:18 pm
- Dreamy: Hell Wolf-kun
- Alignment: Chaotic Good
- My boom: Killing You Guys
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Awww I miss the original narrator. And you can still hear him from time to time. And MAN! Ninja Gaiden was a dirty game. But man, I've missed this show.
OMAETACHI, KOROCHU!
- Ninja_Commander
- Hyakkiyakou wo Buttagiru
- Posts: 131
- Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 7:44 am
- Favorite series: There's too many
- 2nd Favorite Series: See previous
- Alignment: Neutral Good
- Location: Where no one can find me
- Contact:
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Its looks good, but I gotta say the subtitles are not timed well. They are showing up late when they start to talk. Plus they got rid of the TaMaGe and the game collections. Thats what made it fun to watch was Arino finding gamecenters or unusual places for old stuff. Plus the dubbed narrator is so bad at saying Arino's name or even just his title for the show. The voice is just so over the top its not funny. And the one other thing about the dub narrator is his mispronunciation of character names.
As much as I'm glad this show is now shown publicly, they just really dropped the ball on it by removing stuff we like to see and ruining certain parts of the show. I hope they drop the dub and stick to subs for everyone plus fix the timing. After seeing your work on most of the shows on here, it feels lame to see subtitles not show up at the right time or even show up on the things that show up in japanese not translated near it. It just bugs me to hell and doesn't feel the same as yours. Here's hoping to see more of GameCenter CX show up from you guys.
As much as I'm glad this show is now shown publicly, they just really dropped the ball on it by removing stuff we like to see and ruining certain parts of the show. I hope they drop the dub and stick to subs for everyone plus fix the timing. After seeing your work on most of the shows on here, it feels lame to see subtitles not show up at the right time or even show up on the things that show up in japanese not translated near it. It just bugs me to hell and doesn't feel the same as yours. Here's hoping to see more of GameCenter CX show up from you guys.
-
- Adventure
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 6:25 am
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
They didn't cut anything. It is the directors cut from one of the DVDs. Also the narrator passed the highest level of the JLPT in 1995 and has lived in Japan for nearly 20 years so I'm going to guess that he knows how to pronounce Japanese names correctly.
- Lunagel
- Mofu~
- Posts: 11232
- Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 9:09 am
- Favorite series: Magiranger
- 2nd Favorite Series: Gekiranger
- Location: Japan
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Kachou I'll give him, but he wayyyyy over stresses the i in Arino. His sounds like Ar-ee-no rather than Ari-no. Also, there is no reason in the world to pronounce "Ryu" as "Raiyu". Are you sure you're not talking about the translator rather than the narrator?
- Ninja_Commander
- Hyakkiyakou wo Buttagiru
- Posts: 131
- Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 7:44 am
- Favorite series: There's too many
- 2nd Favorite Series: See previous
- Alignment: Neutral Good
- Location: Where no one can find me
- Contact:
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Thank you Luna, that's exactly what I'm talking about. The name of japanese people is done is a very specific way like remember when Cardcapters was on tv and they even said Sakura wrong and now its done right, its like that with Arino and Ryu for Ninja Gaiden. ITs the name pronunciation thats getting me right now with the narrator. The translator is doing a good job. Its just the guy speaking it saying it all wrong.
-
- Adventure
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 6:25 am
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
I'm not saying it isn't. I'm saying that it is on purpose. They're whitewashing the show.
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
Wow. That was... ... Wow. I have a feeling EVERY episode is going to be like playing from 6-1 in Ninja Gaiden... Endlessly... But you know what? Like Arino, I will willing continue to walk through Hell if it helps the show and leads eventually to a better release.
That said, however... PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF GOOOOOOD, SUB GCCX!!! PLEASE! I'm sure the Toku fans will understand if they have to take a little break from their shows! Or better yet, team up with the new people on Something Awful and get us our proper GCCX to enjoy while the plebes deal with Kotaku's RGM! Pleeeeeeeeeease!!!!! ;_;
Okay, enough begging. Show of hands, who's going to brave Ninja Gaiden like Arino did? XD
That said, however... PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF GOOOOOOD, SUB GCCX!!! PLEASE! I'm sure the Toku fans will understand if they have to take a little break from their shows! Or better yet, team up with the new people on Something Awful and get us our proper GCCX to enjoy while the plebes deal with Kotaku's RGM! Pleeeeeeeeeease!!!!! ;_;
Okay, enough begging. Show of hands, who's going to brave Ninja Gaiden like Arino did? XD
-
- Adventure
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 6:25 am
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
I'm not even brave enough to watch the episode. I need to work myself up to it.
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
You could just open it one tab, press play, turn off the audio, and then go and do something else in another window. :p
-
- Adventure
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 6:25 am
Re: Kotaku's Retro Game Master
I was wrong about the announcer. They changed who it was from the original sales pitch. But I do have some good news. A third subbing group just released an episode. I'm not sure if I'm allowed to link to the torrent on here though. They released Kirby's Adventure.