That's a kind of comment that I see a lot, but I don't think that is totally accurate. I mean, most of the people I know who didn't like Yami (me included) don't dislike it because is different, we dislike it because we find it BAD.Phoenix512 wrote:It seems like to me that this show is what you guys wanted after Yami. You complain about the Horrors being the same so you got more unique Horrors. You complain about the Makai Knights being all CG so you got the partial return of the suits. You complain that it wasn't like the original two seasons so it returned to that format and being more related to the original characters. Now to say you guys aren't completely wrong that it could have been a lot better but admit that it was more what you wanted from Garo than Yami was.
Maybe it's time for Garo to take a break and reevaluate itself for a year before coming back again. Also some of you need to stop comparing the new guys to the old ones. You got the old ones so high that the new ones don't have a chance to surpass them ever.
I am totally opened for new things, I enjoyed Soukoku no maryuu a lot and I am eager to watch the anime. Heck, I actually enjoyed some of YWTM episodes, they had awesome moments and the script sometimes wasn't all that bad.
So the people can like or dislike Makai no hana for many reasons, but they don't necessarily have to be related with comparison with the previous seasons, and the same happens with YWTM:
On the other hand, YWTM was the only season in which Amemiya didn't work, so I don't think that they did Makai no hana to please the fans who disliked YWTM. They did it like this because this is the way Amemiya sees and conceives Garo universei, and he probably would have done the same without YWTM existing previously.